Autodesk Smoke 2013 Review Part 1: The Migration



The first time we got a preview of Smoke 2013 at last year’s NAB show it was very impressive and we eagerly awaited the final release this year. Now, that we’ve had a chance to play with it we’re still excited about the potential of Smoke 2013 but our initial attempt to get up to speed on the software has us a little less enthused. Smoke just isn’t as intuitive as we had hoped and the transition from a traditional NLE and effects package may take some time.  So while some experienced Smoke users may find this latest iteration easier to master we were having a harder time.

For this review we worked with two active bay area pros who are experienced using Final Cut, Premiere, Vegas, After Effects, Edius..etc and regularly do broadcast and corporate work.  The iniital conclusion from two independent pros is; “Smoke is hard”. This isn’t really a review of the software in action but rather a review of the initial migration form say Final Cut/CS6 + After Effects  to simply using Smoke 2013.  Everyone's excited by the possibility of working entirely in smoke but getting there will take some time.

Pro 1 writes:
As I try to find ways to break into the "Autodesk Way of Thinking", I keep running into roadblocks. My initial perception is that AutoDesk has created a basic screen layout for Smoke 2013 that is similar to the standard NLEs. But beneath the surface is a way of thinking that is very different from Final Cut or Premiere.

For example, last night I just spent about 20-minutes trying to use the resize filter on a clip. In Final Cut I can resize and move a video clip in just a few clicks. In Smoke...well...I'm still not sure exactly how to do it and the help menu didn't really help, which brings me to another point: I'm finding it hard to find tutorials online that are specifically helpful to what I want to learn.

There is an abundance of material out there, but I just haven't had time to wade through it to find the good stuff yet. And many of the tutorials "assume knowledge" that I don't yet have. On the other hand, I find it really easy to find helpful tutorials for Final Cut, Premiere, Photoshop, etc. The user-community must simply be larger and more robust for these other programs.

On the flip side, I'm excited about what may be Smoke's biggest strength for editors like me. If I can get past these initial hurdles, I think Smoke offers a way of editing that is not only very powerful, but requires a lot less "round tripping". Instead of using multiple programs like Final Cut, Photoshop, After Effects, etc to complete a project, I may be able to do it all in Smoke. And so, if I can learn Smoke, then it's possible that I won't have to spend as much time mastering all those other programs.

Here's the catch. When I first started editing with Final Cut Pro, I fell in love. I had been trying to learn Avid and found it very frustrating. But the "Apple Way of Thinking" in Final Cut just immediately made sense to me. Once I learned something, I could put it in my tool bag and use it any time I wanted. It wasn't hard to remember stuff. And so I'm concerned that, in the end, I will be unhappy with Smoke if it is just too complicated. On the other hand, I'm hopeful that Smoke will soon begin to feel more like Photoshop: very complicated, lots of depth...but so useful that it's worth the effort.

Pro 2 Writes:
Autodesk says Smoke is designed for video editors who need to do more than just edit.  That's pretty much all of us these days. I’m one of those people that will take the time to figure out a program if I think the payoff will be worth it. I’m excited about Smoke 2013 because of the potential of having such a powerful all in one program. And I’m a long term Autodesk fan. I still use Combustion and actually prefer it to After Effects although these days I’m forced to use After Effects much more to stay current.

I was expecting Smoke 2013 to be more intuitive than it is. I moved off the Mac platform after Apple decided it was no longer making Mac towers, at least not as frequently as they used to. I’ve been working on PC workstations for several years and had fully committed to the Windows platform.

Along comes Smoke 2013 and I now have a reason to by a new Mac tower, which Apple finally decided to release in the fall. That’s how excited I am about Smoke. I literally will invest in a new tower just to run it.

To be fair I’ve been running Smoke on an underpowered MacBook Pro. I'm not trying to evaluate the performance and speed but rather just get familiar with the work flow to see if I really could move from CS6 and Vegas to Smoke 2013.

Combustion and even Cleaner Xl back in the day were always a little quirky and never intuitive as other software to me. However, with some work I was able to get comfortable and master the software. My initial foray into Smoke 2013 is a different story. Even after watching the tutorials, I still find myself stumbling through the interface to the point of frustration and simply closing the program down. I normally love playing with new software and I want to love Smoke 2013 but the learning curve is getting in the way.

So that’s where we are right now.  We're about 60 days in with two pros who are actively working on video projects and would love to learn Smoke 2013 but are struggling to get up to speed. To be fair, we’ll give these pros more time to see what the reaction is once they actually figure out how to do real work with Smoke 2013.  The release of the new Mac Pros will help as well.  

Visit Autodesk for more information on Smoke 2013.

Fresh Reviews

Moog Subsequent 37

Apr 17, 2018 Production
Default Image
great demo of this amazing synth

An Incredible Story of Life,…

Dec 31, 2017 House Stuff
Default Image

Lynx E22 Versus RME Audio…

Sep 06, 2017 Production
When it comes to audio cards that go inside your workstation the options are getting more…

Amazing A-Frame in LA

Nov 06, 2016 House Stuff
Default Image
yes, at one time, this was a kit you could buy from Sears.

How to Make a Candy Corn…

Oct 27, 2016 House Stuff
Default Image
A good one for the season and fun for the kids.

How to Install a Rain Barrel

Oct 01, 2016 House Stuff
Default Image
Get ready for the rainy season.

A Couple’s Garage Becomes…

Sep 14, 2016 House Stuff
Default Image
This is a pretty cool zen lifestyle

Edius 8.22 Review - Powerful…

Sep 13, 2016 Production
EDIUS 8
Edius 8.22 from Grass Valley is the latest update that adds LUT and tracking support.…

See a Funky Beach Home Made…

Jul 08, 2015 House Stuff
Default Image

Ultimate Man Cave: Missile…

Apr 08, 2015 House Stuff
Default Image
This is awesome!

NVIDIA Quadro K4200 Review

Jan 09, 2015 Production
We've been doing an extended review of the Quadro K4200 and it's been rock solid. It's…

JBL EON206P Portable PA Review

Jan 08, 2015 Production
The JBL EON206P portable PA system surprised us with how much sonic punch it packs into a…

Panasonic AJ-PX270…

Jan 06, 2015 Production
Default Image
The PX270 is an amazing HD camera for ENG, corporate and documentary work. Over the years…

Boris FX BCC 9 Review 2014

Nov 26, 2014 Production
If you buy only 1 VFX package for your NLE this year we highly recommend Boris Continuum…

HP Z230 Workstation Review

Jul 15, 2014 Computers and Stuff
The HP Z230 is a single CPU workstation that looks similar to other workstations in the Z…

Logitech Harmony 650 Remote…

Jul 05, 2014 Electronics
The Logitech Harmony 650 Universal remote is super easy to program and works great but is…

Sony Vegas Pro 13 Review

Jun 24, 2014 Production
Sony Vegas Pro 13 feels a lot like Vegas Pro 12 with some minor updates to the UI. It…

Samsung 1TB 840 EVO SSD Review

Jun 11, 2014 Computers and Stuff
Samsung 840 EVO 1TB SSD is one of the best values in a high performance SSD. We used it…

Convergent Design Odyssey7Q…

Jun 09, 2014 Production
The Odyssey7Q combines a high quality 7.7 OLED monitor with an SSD based recorder to…

Pixelan DissolveMaster Review

Feb 13, 2014 Production
Default Image
Pixelan Software’s DissolveMaster provides endless options for creating compelling…

Beautiful Holiday Tabletops…

Dec 13, 2013 House Stuff
Default Image
Check out the hurricanes. Super cool.This design is moderm but still warm and welcoming,…

Houzz - Home Remodeling and…

Nov 22, 2013 House Stuff
Default Image
If you're doing any work on your home you have to check out houzz.

iZotope RX3 Advanced Review

Oct 23, 2013 Production
Izotope RX3 Advanced is an elegantly designed suite of audio restoration tools with a…

Grass Valley Edius Pro 7…

Sep 20, 2013 Production
The good news is Edius 7 should benefit from a more open platform going forward. The bad…

The Akai MPX8 Portable Sample…

Aug 29, 2013 Production
The Akai MPX8 is a portable sample player with decent playability and sound for a hundred…

Hot and Funky

The Fall Colors of New…

Sep 22, 2016 Art and Expression
Default Image
Another reason to love the fall.

Take the Mesmerizing Tour of…

Sep 09, 2015 Art and Expression
Default Image

Incredible Bodypaint Art -…

Apr 02, 2015 Art and Expression
Default Image
This is awesome.

Excuse me, Do you have the…

Jan 02, 2015 Art and Expression
Default Image
http://whatcolourisit.scn9a.org/This is so cool. A website that translates the current…

Man Turns His House Into…

Dec 21, 2014 Art and Expression
Default Image
This is one house you have to see in action to believe. Amazing!!!

Danny Macaskill...Always…

Oct 06, 2014 Art and Expression
Default Image

Logitech Harmony 650 Remote…

Jul 05, 2014 Electronics
The Logitech Harmony 650 Universal remote is super easy to program and works great but is…

Brian Williams Snoop Dog Mix

Apr 23, 2014 Art and Expression
Default Image
So, so good. Brilliant editing.

2014 BRING IT ON!

Jan 02, 2014 Art and Expression
Default Image

24 Hours of Happy - Just…

Dec 18, 2013 Art and Expression
This is one of our favorite creative projects we've seen in 2013. Great song and steady…

HP Unleashes Thunderbolt for…

Sep 12, 2013 Technology
The new HP ZBook 17 Mobile Workstation should make a lot of mobile video editors happy.…

Bose SoundLink II Mobile…

Feb 21, 2013 Electronics
The Bose SoundLink II mobile Bluetooth speaker sounds very good, is extremely easy to use…

Sanyo eneloop Rechargeable AA…

Feb 02, 2013 Electronics
Sanyo eneloop AA rechargeable batteries are good a place to start when investing in…

iPad mini Versus Kindle Fire…

Dec 27, 2012 Electronics
The Kindle Fire HD is an appealing product and a great choice if you consider it a media…

The Roku 2 XS Review

Dec 18, 2012 Electronics
The Roku 2 XS is a great gift for anyone with a high speed Internet connection that wants…

Fuji XP50 Waterproof Camera…

Jul 24, 2012 Electronics
The Fuji XP50 waterproof camera is an affordable option that takes pretty good photos…

How to Install an SSD Drive…

Jul 07, 2012 Technology
Default Image
If you've been thinking about upgrading your system to an SSD there's never been a better…

How to Install an SSD Drive…

Jun 08, 2012 Technology
Default Image
Here's a short video that shows you how to install a solid state drive in your notebook…

7200RPM Hard Drive Versus an…

Jun 02, 2012 Technology
Default Image
Another reason to love SSDs. Those faster boot times really add up over time. And wih OS…

LED versus Plasma versus LCD:…

Apr 12, 2012 Technology
Samsung is cranking out some amazing smart televisions with Internet apps and menu…

How To Choose A Memory Card…

Mar 05, 2012 Technology
Default Image
There are lots of suppliers of memory cards out there. SanDisk breaks it down in under 2…

First Android OS Watch: Sneak…

Mar 01, 2012 Technology
Default Image
Synch this to your smart phone using Bluetooth and you can do quite a bi with this watch…

ASUS ZENBOOK™ Ultrabook…

Jan 13, 2012 Technology
Default Image
One of our favorite new products from CES is the new ASUS ZENBOOK. This is going to be a…

Sonos Play:3 Review

Jul 25, 2011 Electronics
The Sonos Play:3 sounds great for background music but is slightly underpowered and lacks…

Join Me - The Fastest and…

Jul 15, 2011 Technology
If you’re looking for the fastest and simplest way to share what you see on your computer…